Capt Safdar Defamation Notice Seeks Rs10bn Damages
The Capt Safdar defamation notice demands a public apology, the withdrawal of allegedly defamatory remarks and the removal of videos carrying them.
Retired Captain Muhammad Safdar, the husband of Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz and a former member of the National Assembly, served the Rs10 billion notice on Advocate Mian Dawood.
The notice, dated November 20, was issued through Rawalpindi-based lawyer Majad Ali Butt under Section 10 of the Punjab Defamation Act 2024.
Capt Safdar defamation notice: what it demands
It demands that Dawood apologise within 14 days on the same platforms and in leading English and Urdu newspapers, retract the statements, remove the videos, pay Rs10 billion and refrain from repeating the remarks.
If Dawood fails to comply, Safdar has warned that he will approach the Special Tribunal set up under the Defamation Act. Dawood confirmed to Dawn that he had received the notice and said he would respond after examining it.
The notice cites three items: a two-minute video uploaded on YouTube on September 24, a news channel interview aired on October 29 and a video statement made after last month’s Supreme Court Bar Association elections.
It argues that free speech cannot become a licence for vulgar abuse and that Dawood was expected to show restraint. The notice describes Dawood as an unrelated third party who responded with malice to a dispute in which he had no direct role.
How the dispute over Ahsan Bhoon’s degree began
The row began with Safdar’s demand that Ahsan Bhoon, a former president of the Supreme Court Bar Association, produce his LLB degree. The notice says that matter is before the Supreme Court and the Pakistan Bar Council.
Safdar raised the issue in late September, when he called for verification of the degrees of prominent lawyers, including Bhoon. Bhoon is a close associate of Law Minister Azam Nazeer Tarar and heads the Independent Group, also known as the Asma Jahangir Group. Safdar had announced the formation of his own group, the Quaid-i-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah Group.
The notice claims Safdar had said he would apologise if Bhoon’s degree proved genuine. It says Dawood then intervened on Bhoon’s behalf and made personal remarks instead of addressing the degree question.
The notice also alleges Dawood made personal remarks about Safdar’s marriage and private life on social media, which it says damaged his reputation.
The case has already reached the tribunal
Bhoon has already filed a Rs5 billion defamation suit against Safdar over remarks questioning his LLB degree. The Punjab Defamation Tribunal admitted the suit and issued a notice to Safdar.
Safdar had also moved a complaint with the Judicial Commission of Pakistan to seek verification of Bhoon’s educational qualifications. The Pakistan Bar Council later confirmed that Bhoon’s degree was genuine, along with the degrees of its other elected members. The council said the returning officers for its 2020 and 2025 elections had verified the degrees from the members’ universities.
The Supreme Court Bar Association elections held last month form part of the same backdrop. Amjad Shah won the association’s presidency in that vote, which followed weeks of campaigning by rival lawyer groups.
Defamation claims between politicians and lawyers are now common in Punjab. A separate Rs5 billion defamation notice was served in another political row this month, and Maryam Nawaz’s own camp has also replied to defamation claims in the past.
What happens next
Dawood has 14 days from the notice to apologise, retract the remarks and remove the videos. His response will decide whether the matter ends with an apology or moves to the Special Tribunal under the Defamation Act.
If the case reaches the tribunal, it will join Bhoon’s Rs5 billion claim against Safdar, which is already admitted for hearing. Both cases turn on the same chain of events.
Frequently asked questions
What does the Capt Safdar defamation notice demand?
It demands a public apology, retraction of the remarks, removal of the videos and payment of Rs10 billion in damages, all within 14 days.
Who sent the notice and under which law?
Captain Muhammad Safdar sent it through Rawalpindi lawyer Majad Ali Butt under Section 10 of the Punjab Defamation Act 2024. It is dated November 20.
What started the dispute?
Safdar demanded that former Supreme Court Bar Association president Ahsan Bhoon produce his LLB degree. The Pakistan Bar Council later declared it genuine.
Has Advocate Mian Dawood responded?
Dawood confirmed to Dawn that he received the notice and said an appropriate response would be sent after examining it.
What happens if Dawood does not comply?
Safdar will approach the Special Tribunal under the Defamation Act. Bhoon’s separate Rs5 billion defamation suit against Safdar is already admitted for hearing.





