Top 5 This Week

spot_img

Related Posts

LHC Acquits Father Who Killed His Daughter’s Attacker

LHC Acquits Father Who Killed His Daughter’s Attacker

The Lahore High Court has acquitted a man serving a seven-year sentence for killing the man who had sexually assaulted his daughter. The LHC acquits father ruling came in a 10-page verdict by Justice Muhammad Waheed Khan, who accepted Abdul Wahid’s appeal and declared the decision of the Nankana Sahib additional sessions court dated 29 April last year null and void.

The court ordered the immediate release of the appellant if he was not wanted in any other case. It also rejected a petition by complainant Ali Shan seeking enhancement of the sentence.

The trial court had sentenced the man to seven years in prison, a fine of Rs50,000 and compensation of Rs200,000. The High Court found that the trial court’s reasoning did not hold up, and that the case against the appellant rested on conjecture rather than proof.

LHC acquits father: what the court found

During the hearing, the court observed that the right of self-defence had been recognised in the case of killing a person who trespassed into the accused’s home to commit sexual assault. The High Court noted that the trial court had failed to justify its claim that the accused had exceeded the right to self-defence.

The verdict termed the trial court’s decision as based on conjecture. It observed that the presence of eyewitnesses was dubious, a point the trial court had itself acknowledged. Where the trial court had accepted that the eyewitness account was doubtful, the High Court held, it could not then rely on that account to sustain a conviction.

The Lahore High Court has acquitted appellants in other cases where the trial record did not support the conviction. In October it acquitted a man in a 295-B case, and its orders are regularly tested on appeal. The courts remain busy with high-profile matters, including the 190m case, whose hearing has been fixed for November 25.

The right of self-defence

Pakistani law recognises the right of private defence, which allows a person to use force, including lethal force in defined circumstances, to protect the body of oneself or another person against an unlawful attack. The right is not unlimited. It must be proportionate to the threat, and it ends when the threat ends.

The question in this case was whether the appellant had gone beyond that right. The trial court said he had. The High Court disagreed, holding that the trial court had not justified that finding on the evidence before it. The court accepted that the man who was killed had entered the accused’s home to commit a sexual assault, and that the right of self-defence applied in those circumstances.

The distinction matters because it decides where lawful defence ends and unlawful killing begins. A court that finds the accused exceeded the right must explain how, with reference to the facts. The High Court found no such explanation in the trial court’s judgment.

What happens next

Abdul Wahid is to be released at once unless he is wanted in another case. The complainant’s petition for enhancement of the sentence stands rejected, so the acquittal is the final word from the High Court unless it is challenged before the Supreme Court.

The case will be read closely by lawyers who handle self-defence claims, because it sets out how an appellate court should test a trial court’s finding that the right was exceeded. Police in Punjab have pursued a separate high-profile investigation this month, after they arrested two men in the Kanganpur kheer case following the deaths of five people.

The Federal Investigation Agency has pursued its own court-linked cases too, including one over a fake Indian passport used for travel to France. For the family in Nankana Sahib, the verdict closes a case that began with a trial court conviction in April last year.

Frequently asked questions

Who did the Lahore High Court acquit?

The court acquitted Abdul Wahid, who was serving a seven-year sentence for killing the man who had sexually assaulted his daughter. Justice Muhammad Waheed Khan accepted his appeal in a 10-page verdict.

Why was the conviction set aside?

The High Court held that the trial court’s decision was based on conjecture, that the presence of eyewitnesses was dubious, and that the trial court had failed to justify its claim that the accused had exceeded the right to self-defence.

What had the trial court ordered?

The Nankana Sahib additional sessions court had sentenced Abdul Wahid to seven years in prison, a fine of Rs50,000 and compensation of Rs200,000 on 29 April last year.

Will the man be released?

Yes. The High Court ordered his immediate release if he is not wanted in any other case. It also rejected the complainant Ali Shan’s petition seeking enhancement of the sentence.

Can the acquittal be challenged?

The acquittal is the final word from the High Court unless it is challenged before the Supreme Court. The complainant’s petition for enhancement of the sentence stands rejected.

Feature Pakistan News Desk
Feature Pakistan News Desk
Feature Pakistan News Desk is the editorial team of Feature Pakistan, an independent digital news platform based in Pakistan. The desk reports national, world, business, sports, technology, health and education news, and every story is cross-checked against multiple sources before it is published. To reach the newsroom — including for corrections — email featurepakistanofficial@gmail.com or use the Contact page at featurepakistan.com/contact-us/.

opinion