IHC Tells Bari Imam House Caretaker to Prove Ownership
The Islamabad High Court (IHC) on Monday disposed of a writ petition challenging the sealing of Bari Imam House in Nurpur Shahan, directing the petitioner to approach the Capital Development Authority (CDA) with documented proof of ownership.
Justice Ayyaz Shaukat, who authored the judgment, declined to grant the declaratory relief sought. The court said the CDA was free to proceed in accordance with the law if the petitioner failed to produce the documents. Feature Pakistan reported earlier that the CDA planned to challenge the order de-sealing the premises.
The land behind the Bari Imam House case
The core dispute is whether the structure stands on exempted shrine land or on land acquired by the CDA in 1963. The court observed that this turned on contested questions of fact that could not be resolved in constitutional jurisdiction on bare assertions.
The CDA sealed the premises on 30 October in a joint operation with the district administration, saying the property is an unauthorised encroachment on government land acquired under Award No. 4/DC CDA/1963, with compensation paid to the landowners.
According to the CDA, the land comprising Khasras No. 435, 582, 591, 592 and 593 formed part of that acquisition and contains no building by the name of “Bari Imam House” in the official record. The shrine’s land is recorded on entirely different Khasra numbers, 277, 665, 677, 678, 679 and 680, across the road.
What the petitioner argued
The petitioner, Muhammad Akmal, is the caretaker of the premises, which stand opposite the shrine of Bari Imam Sarkar. He claimed the premises comprise a mosque, a langar khana and wuzu (ablution) facilities, and that the land was exempted shrine property never acquired by the CDA.
He also alleged that the sealing took place without any notice or opportunity of hearing, in violation of several constitutional provisions. During the hearing, his counsel conceded that the property was not his own and that he was merely a caretaker of the shrine, and that he did not possess the relevant documents, which were held by the CDA.
The court noted that the petitioner had produced no ownership documents, and that his counsel had candidly conceded that the relevant record lay with the CDA and the Islamabad Capital Territory (ICT) administration.
What the court ordered
The court directed the petitioner to submit his ownership documents, if any, before the CDA within five days. The CDA must then afford him a hearing, consider the documents alongside its own record, and decide the matter by a speaking order within two days after that.
If the petitioner does not submit the documents or does not wish to do so, the CDA will be at liberty to proceed in accordance with the law. The court clarified that nothing in its order should be construed as an expression of opinion on the merits of title or possession.
The CDA’s counsel, Kashif Ali Malik, had argued that the petition was not maintainable and that the occupation amounted to encroachment on CDA land. The interim order of 3 November, which had directed the de-sealing of the premises and restrained demolition, now stands merged in the final order. Any person aggrieved by the CDA’s decision may avail the remedy available under the law.
The wider CDA picture
The case is one of several in which the CDA’s enforcement work has reached the courts. The Federal Constitutional Court has ordered the CDA to pay land compensation within six months in a separate matter, and the authority has also carried out demolitions along the Islamabad Expressway. The CDA’s pink electric bus service for women in Islamabad shows the other side of the authority’s work, as it expands services while it defends its land record.
Frequently asked questions
What did the IHC decide?
It disposed of the writ petition challenging the sealing of Bari Imam House and directed the petitioner to submit ownership documents to the CDA within five days. If he fails to do so, the CDA may proceed in accordance with the law.
Who filed the petition?
Muhammad Akmal, the caretaker of the premises, which stand opposite the shrine of Bari Imam Sarkar in Nurpur Shahan, Islamabad.
What is the land dispute about?
Whether the structure stands on exempted shrine land or on land the CDA acquired in 1963 under Award No. 4/DC CDA/1963. The two sides cite different Khasra numbers in the land record.
What happens next?
The petitioner has five days to submit his documents to the CDA. The CDA must then hear him, weigh the documents against its own record, and decide by a speaking order within two days after that.
Did the court decide who owns the land?
No. The court expressly said nothing in its order should be construed as an opinion on the merits of title or possession.





