FBR Tax Split Could Grow Informal Economy
The FBR tax split could push businesses outside the tax net and expand Pakistan’s informal economy, a think tank has warned. The Federal Board of Revenue’s decision separates income tax and sales tax administration.
The Policy Research Institute of Market Economy (PRIME) criticised the move, saying it reverses a 2009 reform that brought income tax, sales tax and federal excise under one body, the Inland Revenue Service, so a single officer could handle a company’s full tax affairs.
Last week, the FBR separated sales tax and federal excise administration from income tax within the Inland Revenue Service. Dr Muhammad Sarmad Qureshi was appointed the first Member of Sales Tax and Federal Excise Duty, and Muhammad Anwar was named chief of these taxes. A separate stream of officers starts next month.
Why the FBR tax split worries the think tank
PRIME argues that splitting the administration will weaken one of the main tools for catching tax evasion. Businesses report overlapping financial information in their income tax and sales tax returns, so a company hiding sales to cut its sales tax bill may also be hiding income. When one officer handles both taxes, a gap in one return can expose evasion in the other. Separate officers could weaken that link.
The FBR justifies the change by pointing to weak domestic sales tax collection, down 1.7 percent last fiscal year even as import-stage collections rose 17 percent. PRIME accepts the numbers are poor, but says the split is the wrong cure.
Registered businesses could also face higher costs, dealing with two commissioners, separate notices and different interpretations of the same transactions, while firms outside the net avoid all of that.
A fragmented tax system
The institute also pointed to a deeper problem: Pakistan’s value-added tax is fragmented, with goods taxed federally and services provincially, creating separate rates, returns, exemptions and requirements.
PRIME said a harmonised value-added tax on goods and services, with a lower unified rate and fewer exemptions, would raise collection more effectively. Pakistan’s tax-to-GDP ratio stayed at 10.3 percent during the past two fiscal years, despite repeated reforms and billions of dollars in loans.
The FBR has already moved this month to split tax policy from enforcement, and it has introduced a faceless system for income tax appeals.
Cash, enforcement and the informal economy
The concerns come as the cash economy faces fresh scrutiny. National Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Authority (NAML and CTA) Chairman Mushtaq Sukhera told a Senate committee that reliance on cash drives illicit activity, and that a paper proposing a shift to a digital economy has gone to the government.
The same committee heard that bank staff have acted as conveyor belts for money laundering, with funds moving through accounts held in the names of ordinary people, including one in a bulldozer driver’s name that handled Rs12 billion.
Senator Dilawar Khan cautioned against aggressive enforcement targeting legitimate taxpayers already registered with the FBR, while Senator Abdul Qadir criticised corruption inside the tax administration, citing a dispute at the Regional Tax Office in Lahore over bribe money.
What would work better
PRIME’s argument is that structure is not the problem. A simpler, unified tax on goods and services, with fewer exemptions and a lower rate, would bring more firms into the net than a split that adds paperwork for those already paying.
The International Monetary Fund has urged Pakistan to broaden its tax base to support growth and has flagged the tax system as unfair. Exports have reached a record $11.4 billion in the first four months of the fiscal year, but the tax base has not kept pace.
The new sales tax stream starts work next month, and its first test will be whether collections rise without pushing more trade into the shadows.
Frequently asked questions
What did the FBR change?
Last week it separated sales tax and federal excise administration from income tax within the Inland Revenue Service, reversing a 2009 reform that had unified them.
Who warned against the split?
The Policy Research Institute of Market Economy (PRIME), a think tank, warned that the split could expand the informal economy and weaken checks on tax evasion.
Why does the split matter for evasion?
Businesses report overlapping figures in income tax and sales tax returns. One officer handling both can spot a gap in one return that exposes evasion in the other.
What does PRIME propose instead?
A harmonised value-added tax on goods and services, with a lower unified rate and fewer exemptions, which it says would raise collection more effectively.
How much tax does Pakistan collect?
The tax-to-GDP ratio stayed at 10.3 percent during the past two fiscal years, despite repeated reforms and billions of dollars in loans.





