Pakistan Calls Indus Waters Treaty Move Outlaw Behaviour
Pakistan has told the United Nations that India’s unilateral decision to place the Indus Waters Treaty in abeyance is “outlaw behaviour” that violates international law and threatens the water security of more than 240 million people.
First Secretary Ansar Shah delivered the charge at a UN Security Council meeting on natural resources and conflict prevention, in Pakistan’s right of reply to remarks by the Indian representative.
“That is not treaty law; it is outlaw behaviour,” Shah said. He said weaponising the waters on which more than 240 million Pakistanis depend was not a “reassessment” of the treaty but an act of coercion that created conditions which could lead to conflict.
Pakistan’s position was first presented by Ambassador Usman Jadoon, the Deputy Permanent Representative of Pakistan, at an Arria-formula meeting convened by Liberia on November 18 on natural resources and conflict prevention.
What the Indus Waters Treaty says
The 1960 treaty governs sharing of the Indus river system. The eastern rivers, the Ravi, Beas and Sutlej, went mainly to India, while Pakistan received rights over the western rivers, the Indus, Jhelum and Chenab, subject to specified Indian uses.
Shah said the treaty contained no provision that allowed either party to place it unilaterally in abeyance. He answered India’s argument that the world had changed since 1960 by noting that the UN Charter was even older.
“Does India consider that outdated as well?” he asked. He also accused New Delhi of disregarding Security Council resolutions on Jammu and Kashmir.
Jadoon cited the August 31 award of the Court of Arbitration, which found the treaty remained fully in force and India remained bound by its obligations, rejecting India’s grounds for suspending or ending it.
Pakistan’s case on natural resources
Jadoon said natural resources should serve sustainable development, shared prosperity and peace, rather than become sources of exploitation and conflict. He warned that external interference, commercial interests, historical grievances, ethnic tensions, political exclusion and weak institutions could combine to turn resource wealth into a source of instability.
He cited the Democratic Republic of Congo, where mineral wealth had sustained conflict instead of bringing prosperity. He set out three priorities: fixing the underlying political and governance problems; disrupting illicit financial flows through international cooperation; and making sure resource-rich developing countries gained from investment, technology transfer, local processing and skills development.
He added that transit and consuming states, multinational corporations and financial institutions also had to help, through stronger traceability, responsible supply chains and information-sharing.
On shared resources, particularly water, he said cooperation among neighbours and peaceful dispute settlement were essential for regional stability, citing UN Security Council Resolution 2788 and Article 33 of the UN Charter.
India defends its position
India’s Permanent Representative, Ambassador Harish Parvathaneni, defended existing international mechanisms for managing resource disputes, citing the Kimberley Process, which helped curb the trade in conflict diamonds while protecting legitimate commerce.
Shah, exercising his right of reply, accused the Indian representative of resorting to deflection and denial rather than addressing the treaty dispute. He alleged that Indian forces had killed more than 100,000 Kashmiris since 1989 and continued to suppress their fundamental rights and deny them self-determination.
He also rejected what he called frivolous remarks by the Indian representative about Pakistan’s domestic affairs, describing Pakistan as a constitutional and democratic country. He accused the ruling Hindutva establishment of promoting discrimination against minorities, suppressing free speech and inciting religious hatred, and he urged India to abandon its “hubris” and comply with international law and its obligations under treaties and Security Council resolutions.
The exchange follows months of tension over the treaty. Feature Pakistan earlier reported warnings from Islamabad over the treaty and Gilani’s warning that blocking Pakistan’s water would be an act of war, alongside wider regional diplomacy including Musadik Malik’s Delhi visit and Pakistan’s food diplomacy push at the UN.
Frequently asked questions
What did Pakistan say about the Indus Waters Treaty at the UN?
First Secretary Ansar Shah called India’s decision to place the treaty in abeyance “outlaw behaviour” that violated international law and threatened water for more than 240 million people.
Can India place the treaty in abeyance on its own?
No, Pakistan says. Shah told the UN the 1960 treaty has no provision for unilateral abeyance, and he cited an August 31 Court of Arbitration award finding it remains fully in force.
Which rivers does the treaty allocate to Pakistan?
Pakistan received rights over the western rivers, the Indus, Jhelum and Chenab, while the eastern rivers, the Ravi, Beas and Sutlej, were allocated mainly to India.
What did India say in response?
India’s Permanent Representative Harish Parvathaneni defended existing international mechanisms for managing resource disputes, citing the Kimberley Process on conflict diamonds.
What did the Court of Arbitration decide about the treaty?
In its award of August 31, the Court of Arbitration found that the Indus Waters Treaty remained fully in force and that India continued to be bound by its obligations. The court also rejected the grounds India advanced to justify suspending or ending the agreement.




