GBA-16 Tribunal Suspends Diamer Repoll Results
GBA-16 tribunal suspends Diamer repoll results in a fresh twist to the Gilgit-Baltistan Assembly contest, after the election tribunal put the official outcome on hold and summoned top election officials to appear in person.
Gilgit-Baltistan Election Tribunal Judge Mushtaq Mohammad suspended the official results of re-polling at three stations of GBA-16, Diamer-II, on Wednesday. He adjourned the hearing until Thursday.
The tribunal had suspended the assembly membership of PPP candidate Attaullah Shah on November 6. It had ordered re-polling at three stations in the constituency on the plea of Istehkam-i-Pakistan Party candidate Imam Malik. It had also sought a report from the Gilgit-Baltistan election commissioner after the re-poll.
The order comes days after the repoll result was announced. Shah had won the repoll by 85 votes, according to the final result issued late on Monday night.
Diamer repoll results: what the tribunal heard
On Wednesday, the Gilgit-Baltistan Election Commission submitted a detailed report to the tribunal. The report carried results from two polling stations, but not the third.
The deputy election commissioner told the court that incomplete results had been issued because of disruption at one polling station on polling day. The missing station left the consolidated result open to challenge.
Counsel for Attaullah Shah argued that the tribunal’s order of November 6 had been carried out in full. After re-polling at the three stations, he said, Shah had been declared the returned candidate. Arguments on the matter should not be repeated now, he told the court.
The judge did not accept that position. He directed the returning officer and the Gilgit-Baltistan chief election commissioner to appear in person on Thursday. The summons was issued over non-compliance with Section 88 of the Elections Act, 2017.
The hearing on Thursday will now decide whether the repoll result stands. Until then, the official result stays suspended.
The Wora ballot box case
Police have also registered a case over the disruption at the Wora polling station. The case concerns unidentified armed men who attacked female polling staff and took away ballot boxes before counting on polling day.
Polling officer Dr Aalia Khan said in the first information report that armed men forced their way into the polling station. She said they beat the polling staff and took the ballot boxes away. After some hours, the boxes were returned.
She said the attackers held the polling staff hostage for hours. They forced the staff to sign a handwritten Form-45, the form that records the vote count at a polling station. She said the attackers assaulted the female staff and demanded their arrest and exemplary punishment.
The Wora station was one of the three stations where re-polling took place. The disruption there was also the reason the consolidated result was delayed by more than a day.
How the repoll reached this point
The contest in GBA-16 has run for weeks. The tribunal first suspended Shah’s membership on November 6 and ordered a fresh poll at three stations. Repolling finished on Sunday, but the official results for two stations did not arrive until Monday night.
Shah won the repoll by 85 votes under the final result, polling 6,758 votes against 6,673 for Malik. The Gilgit-Baltistan Election Commission issued the result in Form 49 late on Monday night.
The delay had already caused protests. Supporters blocked the Karakoram Highway for around 10 hours while they waited for the result. The count at the combined male and female station in Gechi had finished on time, but the Sarai female station and the Wora station held up the final tally.
The tribunal’s first intervention came on November 6, when it suspended Shah’s membership and ordered the repoll. Wednesday’s order is the second intervention in the same case, and it leaves the seat in doubt until the tribunal hears the matter again.
Frequently asked questions
What did the GBA-16 tribunal order?
The tribunal suspended the official results of re-polling at three stations of GBA-16, Diamer-II, and adjourned the hearing until Thursday.
Who won the repoll before the suspension?
PPP candidate Attaullah Shah won by 85 votes, polling 6,758 votes against 6,673 for IPP candidate Imam Malik, under the final result issued late on Monday night.
Why were the results suspended?
The election commission submitted results from only two of the three stations. The third result was missing after disruption at one polling station on polling day.
Who has been summoned for Thursday?
The tribunal directed the returning officer and the Gilgit-Baltistan chief election commissioner to appear in person over non-compliance with Section 88 of the Elections Act, 2017.
What happened at the Wora polling station?
Police registered a case after armed men allegedly attacked female polling staff, took ballot boxes away and forced staff to sign a handwritten Form-45.




