Top 5 This Week

spot_img

Related Posts

Fatima Asghar CCTV Footage Emerges in Islamabad Probe

Fatima Asghar CCTV Footage Emerges in Islamabad Probe

Fatima Asghar CCTV footage has emerged, showing the 13-year-old domestic worker being beaten at the official residence of a senior Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) officer in Islamabad before her death on November 14.

The clips, which surfaced on Saturday, show Fatima being struck with a stick as she cries and pleads for mercy, according to The Express Tribune, which has the footage. Photographs seen by the newspaper also show marks of torture and burns on the child’s body. Police said she was subjected to abuse until around 40 minutes before her death.

Fatima worked at the residence, the official accommodation of a Grade-19 FIA officer inside the Islamabad Police Lines Headquarters in H-11. A murder case was registered at Shams Colony police station the day after her death, on her father’s complaint.

Fatima Asghar CCTV footage: what the clips show

The footage is now part of the investigation record. The investigating officer told a court the digital video recorder holding the recordings had gone for forensic analysis, and the court directed that the videos and screenshots on a USB drive be attached to the case file.

Police arrested the FIA officer’s wife, Afshan Ali, and a religious tutor, Qari Ali Raza, in connection with the case. Police said both suspects confessed during interrogation to subjecting the child to torture. On November 18, police recovered a stick and an electric iron allegedly used in the assault. Prosecutors told the court the girl had been burned with the iron.

Prosecutors have also sought permission for polygraph and voice-matching tests on a third suspect, and the magistrate told the investigating officer to widen the probe into whether the child faced bonded labour and exploitation.

Remand extended as probe widens

A judicial magistrate on Friday extended the physical remand of both suspects by three days, after police sought four, Dawn reported. The pair had first been remanded for four days on November 16, a day after their arrest.

The defence argued the child had been treated as a family member and further remand was unnecessary. The court disagreed, noting the medical evidence indicated the girl died after repeated physical torture.

The court order also noted a gap in the record: the FIR states her father, a resident of Rahim Yar Khan, handed her over about three years ago so she could study, but the record contained no material to verify that claim.

What the post-mortem found

The Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences (PIMS) post-mortem documented around 20 major wounds across the child’s body, from head to toe. It found repeated assault caused grievous injuries and severe inflammation, which led to blood clots, thromboembolism and cardiopulmonary arrest.

Prosecutors told the court older wounds pointed to a sustained pattern of abuse, and the child had never been given medical treatment. First Lady Aseefa Bhutto Zardari expressed sorrow, saying no child should face violence, abuse or exploitation, and noting Islamabad’s law bars employing children of Fatima’s age as domestic workers, even with parental consent.

A wider pattern of abuse

Fatima’s death is not an isolated case. In March, a 10-year-old domestic worker in Rawalpindi was allegedly beaten with pipes, deprived of food and water and locked in a room before he escaped to police. In July, six-year-old Allahrakhi was allegedly abused by her employer in Vehari until her father complained and police rescued her.

The cases point to gaps in enforcement. A May report by The Express Tribune found weak implementation of the Punjab Domestic Workers Act, 2019 and poor monitoring of private households, while proposed legislation in Sindh to regulate domestic employment and bar child employment under 16 remains stalled.

Why the law did not protect her

In Islamabad, the Islamabad Capital Territory Domestic Workers Act 2022 prohibits employing children below 16 as domestic workers. Fatima, reportedly 13, should have been protected. Her death raises questions about why existing safeguards failed her.

Feature Pakistan has followed the case from the start: the post-mortem findings pointed to repeated violence, the court first gave police a four-day remand and then extended it by three more days. The footage now sits at the centre of the prosecution file. Weak oversight leaves the most vulnerable workers with little protection: home-based workers in Lahore remain trapped in exploitation on wages as low as Rs50 an hour.

What happens next

The suspects remain in custody while forensic analysis of the recordings continues. The court will review the footage, the post-mortem findings and the recovered objects, and police must also report on whether the child faced bonded labour.

Frequently asked questions

What does the Fatima Asghar CCTV footage show?

The CCTV clips show 13-year-old Fatima Asghar being beaten with a stick as she cries and pleads for mercy at the Islamabad residence where she worked as a domestic helper.

When did Fatima Asghar die?

Fatima Asghar died on November 14 at the official residence of a senior FIA officer inside the Islamabad Police Lines Headquarters. A murder case was registered the next day at Shams Colony police station.

Who has been arrested in the case?

Police arrested the FIA officer’s wife, Afshan Ali, and a religious tutor, Qari Ali Raza. Police said both suspects confessed during interrogation to subjecting the child to torture.

What did the post-mortem report find?

The PIMS post-mortem documented around 20 major wounds across the child’s body and found that repeated assault caused inflammation and blood clots, which led to thromboembolism and cardiopulmonary arrest.

What does the law say about child domestic workers in Islamabad?

The Islamabad Capital Territory Domestic Workers Act 2022 prohibits the employment of children below 16 as domestic workers. Fatima was reportedly 13.

Feature Pakistan News Desk
Feature Pakistan News Desk
Feature Pakistan News Desk is the editorial team of Feature Pakistan, an independent digital news platform based in Pakistan. The desk reports national, world, business, sports, technology, health and education news, and every story is cross-checked against multiple sources before it is published. To reach the newsroom — including for corrections — email featurepakistanofficial@gmail.com or use the Contact page at featurepakistan.com/contact-us/.

opinion