Top 5 This Week

spot_img

Related Posts

Fatima Asghar Post-Mortem Points to Repeated Violence

Fatima Asghar Post-Mortem Points to Repeated Violence

The preliminary Fatima Asghar post-mortem has documented more than 20 injuries on the body of the 13-year-old girl, with doctors saying the pattern points to repeated physical violence, in the first medical account of how the child died at a senior officer’s Islamabad residence.

Sources at the Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences (PIMS) told the Islamabad Tribune the injuries included both recent and older wounds, and the preliminary assessment linked her death to complications from those injuries. The detailed report is still awaited.

Sources at PIMS told The Nation that the initial medical report records more than 20 injuries, including bruising and swelling on the lower limbs, a haematoma in the head, and burns, and puts the cause of death as repeated physical assault causing grievous injuries and severe inflammation.

Fatima Asghar post-mortem: what the doctors found

The key point is the mix of old and new injuries. Doctors read that pattern as evidence of violence over time, rather than a single incident. That reading is preliminary, and the detailed report must confirm the nature and extent of each injury.

Shams Colony police are investigating the death at the residence in Islamabad Police Lines, Sector H-11. Police have obtained CCTV footage from the residence and allege that it shows Fatima being struck.

Investigative sources said Qari Ali Raza, one of the two suspects in custody, told police Afshan Ali, wife of senior officer Muhammad Bin Ashraf, had repeatedly struck Fatima with a stick. Afshan denied assaulting the girl. An earlier report said she acknowledged sometimes striking Fatima with Ali Raza, but denied burning her or severe violence.

Police also said they recovered a clothes iron and sticks they suspect were used to injure Fatima. The reported recovery of the iron has yet to be independently corroborated.

Two suspects on remand

Judicial Magistrate Naima Iffat granted police four days’ physical remand of Afshan and Ali Raza on November 16; police had asked for eight days. The court directed investigators to produce both suspects again on November 20. Feature Pakistan reported that a court granted physical remand of the FIA director’s wife and a qari in the Fatima Asghar case after the two were arrested on Sunday.

Shams Colony police registered FIR No. 619/26 under Section 302 of the Pakistan Penal Code on November 15, on the complaint of Fatima’s father, Asghar Ali. He told police his daughter was studying Quran memorisation and living with relatives at Police Lines, that he was told she had fallen ill, and that after her death he saw marks on her body.

The FIR says the incident took place on the evening of November 14. Dawn reported that the girl was found in critical condition with visible marks on her body, and was taken to hospital, where she died. Her father is from Rahim Yar Khan.

The domestic work question

Police sources described Fatima as a domestic worker at the residence, which Afshan disputed. The question matters because Section 3 of the Islamabad Capital Territory Domestic Workers Act, 2022, bars children under 16 from household work in any capacity.

An Islamabad police officer told Dawn the girl had worked as a housemaid for a couple of years at the official residence allotted to the FIA official when he served in the capital police. Afshan has said the household already employed several workers and had no need to hire Fatima.

If she was working in the house, the employment of a 13-year-old would itself breach the 2022 Act. Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz has ordered special courts for the swift hearing of rape cases, after concern over low conviction rates, and Feature Pakistan reported the charge sheet delay in the Hina Javed case.

Officer withdrawn from FIA posting

The Federal Investigation Agency withdrew Bin Ashraf as director of its Gujranwala Zone and directed him to report to FIA headquarters. The November 15 notification gave no reason. Bin Ashraf, a grade 19 Police Service officer, was abroad when the incident took place, according to police. He has said the girl had lived at his home for a long time and urged a transparent investigation.

The police case now rests on three strands: the medical findings, the CCTV footage, and the statements of the two suspects. A separate case showed how police statements shape an investigation, as Feature Pakistan reported in the Rabia Ahsan case.

What happens next

The detailed post-mortem report is the next step. It must confirm which injuries were recent and which were older. Until it arrives, the cause of death rests on a preliminary assessment, not a final finding. Both suspects will be produced before the court again on November 20.

Frequently asked questions

What did the preliminary post-mortem find?

Sources at the Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences said the examination documented more than 20 injuries, including recent and older wounds, and that the pattern pointed to repeated physical violence. The preliminary assessment linked the death to complications from those injuries.

Who are the suspects in the case?

Afshan Ali, the wife of senior FIA officer Muhammad Bin Ashraf, and Qari Ali Raza are in custody. A judicial magistrate granted police four days’ physical remand of both on November 16.

What does the FIR say?

Shams Colony police registered FIR No. 619/26 under Section 302 of the Pakistan Penal Code on November 15, on the complaint of Fatima’s father, Asghar Ali. It says the incident took place on the evening of November 14 at Police Lines, Sector H-11, and records signs of torture on the girl’s body.

Was Fatima Asghar a domestic worker?

Police sources described her as a domestic worker at the residence. Afshan disputed that account. The question matters because the Islamabad Capital Territory Domestic Workers Act, 2022, bars children under 16 from working in a household.

What happens next in the case?

The detailed post-mortem report is awaited, and both suspects will be produced before the court again on November 20. Police have obtained CCTV footage from the residence, which they allege shows Fatima being struck.

Feature Pakistan News Desk
Feature Pakistan News Desk
Feature Pakistan News Desk is the editorial team of Feature Pakistan, an independent digital news platform based in Pakistan. The desk reports national, world, business, sports, technology, health and education news, and every story is cross-checked against multiple sources before it is published. To reach the newsroom — including for corrections — email featurepakistanofficial@gmail.com or use the Contact page at featurepakistan.com/contact-us/.

opinion