Top 5 This Week

spot_img

Related Posts

FBR Officers Skills Shortage Exposed by Tests

FBR Officers Skills Shortage Exposed by Tests

Only four officers of the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) can handle both sales tax and income tax cases on their own, new assessments have shown, exposing a serious FBR officers skills shortage at the heart of the tax system.

FBR Chairman Rashid Langrial ordered the tests to check how well tax officers understood the two tax systems. The results, compiled by the FBR and reported in the media, show that very few officers can pass tax orders without help.

The findings raise fresh questions about the FBR’s capacity to run its planned split of tax operations, separating sales tax and federal excise work from income tax.

FBR officers skills shortage laid bare by test results

The assessments tested officers on sales tax and income tax separately. Only 15 of 150 officers could independently pass sales tax orders. In income tax, only 14 of 143 officers met the required standard.

Of the 139 officers who sat both assessments, only four showed they could handle cases in both tax categories on their own. The rest could not clear the bar in at least one of the two areas.

Many officers could do part of the work but not finish it. A total of 65 officers in sales tax and 72 in income tax could prepare notices or orders, yet they could not pass them under their own signatures.

Scores were low across the board. No sales tax officer reached the 60 per cent benchmark, and only four income tax officers scored 60 per cent or higher. Average scores stood at 26.4 per cent in sales tax and 33.3 per cent in income tax.

The results were weaker still at the bottom end. A total of 47 sales tax officers and 16 income tax officers scored below 20 per cent, pointing to gaps in their grasp of tax law and legal procedure.

The review process showed gaps too. Only 21 sales tax officers and 28 income tax officers could properly examine the legal aspects of orders prepared by other officials. Just eight officers could review orders in both tax categories.

The assessment covered inland revenue officers in Karachi, according to the training report behind the figures, so the results describe that city’s cadre rather than the whole country. The report also cautioned that its findings, based on three cases in each tax category, should be treated as an initial indicator rather than a full picture.

Why the results matter for the tax split

The findings land as the FBR moves to undo a 17-year-old integration that merged sales tax, federal excise and direct tax administration into one structure. The board has transferred 54 officers to the new setup, and dedicated sales tax units are due to become operational in phases from December 2026.

With only four officers able to handle both tax categories, the restructuring raises questions about whether enough experienced staff will be in place to manage the change. The FBR has already begun to split its tax operations, a move that was expected to improve collection but now faces a staffing test.

For taxpayers, orders passed by officers who cannot clear them on their own can face challenges, delays and appeals.

The assessments come amid wider concern over Pakistan’s tax collection system, which has gone through several rounds of reform but has struggled to lift the country’s tax to GDP ratio. The State Bank governor has said economic resilience needs more than fiscal and external buffers, while investors have shown growing faith in the IMF programme.

The FBR’s customs arm has faced its own scrutiny, with the board placing bridges and barrages on a customs watchlist. The IMF, meanwhile, has pressed Pakistan to end its petrol subsidy scheme as part of the reform agenda.

For now, the results point to a training gap as much as a staffing gap, and the board will need to build its officers’ skills if the new structure is to work.

Frequently asked questions

How many FBR officers can handle both sales tax and income tax cases?

Only four of the 139 officers who sat both assessments showed they could independently handle cases in both tax categories.

How many officers can pass sales tax orders on their own?

Only 15 of 150 sales tax officers could independently pass sales tax orders under their own signatures.

How many officers can pass income tax orders on their own?

Only 14 of 143 income tax officers met the required standard for passing income tax orders independently.

What were the average scores in the assessments?

Average scores were 26.4 per cent in sales tax and 33.3 per cent in income tax. No sales tax officer reached the 60 per cent benchmark.

What is the FBR’s tax split plan?

The FBR is reversing a 17-year-old integration and separating sales tax and federal excise administration from income tax, with dedicated sales tax units due to start work in phases from December 2026.

Feature Pakistan News Desk
Feature Pakistan News Desk
Feature Pakistan News Desk is the editorial team of Feature Pakistan, an independent digital news platform based in Pakistan. The desk reports national, world, business, sports, technology, health and education news, and every story is cross-checked against multiple sources before it is published. To reach the newsroom — including for corrections — email featurepakistanofficial@gmail.com or use the Contact page at featurepakistan.com/contact-us/.

opinion