Top 5 This Week

spot_img

Related Posts

Musadik Malik Calls for Evidence-Based Talks with India

Musadik Malik Calls for Evidence-Based Talks with India

Federal Minister for Climate Change Musadik Malik said on Sunday that any dialogue between Pakistan and India on terrorism must be based on evidence, calling for evidence-based talks with India through a forum where both sides present their facts. He was speaking to reporters in New Delhi during his visit for the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) Civilisational Dialogue Forum, Dawn reported.

Malik is leading Pakistan’s delegation at the forum, which ran from November 20 to 22. He is the first Pakistani minister to visit India since Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari attended an SCO meeting in May 2023.

Evidence-based talks with India

In video clips shared by India’s ANI news agency on Sunday, Malik told Indian reporters he had repeatedly set out Pakistan’s stance.

“I am giving you a stable response that whenever discussions take place, they will be based on evidence, and they will certainly happen,” he said, if New Delhi wanted a lasting solution.

“You must also have some issues, [though] our issues are much greater than yours, and we also need a lot of evidence,” the minister said. “You may bring evidence; we also have evidence that we want to present.”

Malik said Pakistan had repeatedly proposed sharing evidence through bilateral or multilateral forums. “There is only one way to resolve this: we must transparently present all the evidence, all the facts, to one another. We should create a forum where this evidence can be brought to light, and every issue can be addressed based on that foundation,” he said.

He said Pakistan had the biggest stake in ending terrorism. “If anyone has a stake in addressing terrorism, it is us, more than anyone else. That is why we want everything to be brought to light based on evidence, so that we can all work together to confront this terrorism and bring it to an end,” he said.

No bilateral talks on this visit

Malik stressed he had not been invited for bilateral talks. India had invited Pakistan to the SCO forum, a multilateral event, and his invitation was limited to that forum.

“I am your guest. You invited me to a specific forum; I am present before you,” he said, adding he had conveyed the “voice of my heart” to people across the region.

“You are today asking me questions for which you did not invite me. When you invite me for that question, I will appear. However, you first ought to invite me and say ‘we want to speak bilaterally with you’.”

On the Indus Waters Treaty, he said he would comment when invited to do so. He added that he would take part in talks on specific bilateral issues if invited: “When you invite me to discuss those specific issues, I shall be there.”

He pointed instead to the shared climate threat: “when temperatures rise, climate is destroyed, Glofs happen. Glofs and glaciers are blind, they do not know whether to fall on the right or the left,” he said.

The background to the visit

Malik arrived in New Delhi to lead Pakistan’s delegation at the first SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum, and held meetings on the sidelines with ministers from India, Iran, Nepal and other countries. In his forum address on Saturday, he called climate change an “enemy” of civilisations, as Feature Pakistan reported.

India’s foreign minister had said in June 2024 that his country wanted a solution to years-old cross-border terrorism. But the four-day military conflict last year hardened positions and fuelled escalatory rhetoric from India.

The May 2025 confrontation followed an attack on tourists in occupied Kashmir’s Pahalgam, which New Delhi, without evidence, linked to Pakistan. Islamabad denied responsibility and called for a neutral investigation. Deputy Prime Minister Ishaq Dar has since pressed the case for talks with India through diplomatic channels.

Why the water treaty matters

The treaty remains a contentious issue after New Delhi placed it in abeyance in April last year, following the Pahalgam attack and the four-day military conflict.

Following India’s move, Pakistan termed any attempt to suspend its water share an “act of war”, noting the treaty had no provision for unilateral suspension and arguing the move violated the 1969 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties.

On August 31, the Permanent Court of Arbitration ordered India to uphold the treaty. Feature Pakistan covered the court’s order and Pakistan’s case at the United Nations in detail.

The World Bank-brokered 1960 treaty gives Pakistan the western rivers, the Indus, Jhelum and Chenab, and India the eastern rivers, the Ravi, Beas and Sutlej.

Frequently asked questions

What did Musadik Malik say about talks with India?

Malik said any discussion between Pakistan and India on terrorism must be based on evidence. He proposed a forum where both countries transparently present their evidence and address every issue on that basis.

Was Malik in India for bilateral talks?

No. Malik attended the SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum in New Delhi from November 20 to 22. He said he was not invited for bilateral talks and would take part in them only if India extended a formal invitation.

What is the SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum?

It is a multilateral Shanghai Cooperation Organisation event held in New Delhi. Malik led Pakistan’s delegation, addressed the forum on climate change, and held meetings with ministers from India, Iran, Nepal and other countries on the sidelines.

What did Malik say about the Indus Waters Treaty?

He declined to comment on the treaty during this visit, saying he would discuss it when invited to do so. India placed the treaty in abeyance in April 2025 after the Pahalgam attack.

Why is this visit significant?

Malik is the first Pakistani minister to visit India since former foreign minister Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari attended an SCO meeting in May 2023. His visit follows the Pahalgam attack and the four-day military confrontation between the two countries in 2025.

Feature Pakistan News Desk
Feature Pakistan News Desk
Feature Pakistan News Desk is the editorial team of Feature Pakistan, an independent digital news platform based in Pakistan. The desk reports national, world, business, sports, technology, health and education news, and every story is cross-checked against multiple sources before it is published. To reach the newsroom — including for corrections — email featurepakistanofficial@gmail.com or use the Contact page at featurepakistan.com/contact-us/.

opinion