Top 5 This Week

spot_img

Related Posts

FCC Legitimacy Questioned After Bilawal Speech

FCC Legitimacy Questioned After Bilawal Speech

Lawyers say Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari’s speech has put the FCC legitimacy debate back in the spotlight, a year after the PPP helped create the Federal Constitutional Court through the 27th Amendment.

The PPP chairman, who once strongly backed the court, now says the 27th Amendment was passed through “brute majority” rather than consensus. He asked whether the court could work if it enjoyed the confidence of the government alone and not the opposition.

FCC legitimacy: what the lawyers said

Pakistan Bar Council executive member Barrister Salahuddin Ahmed said Bilawal had strongly supported both the 26th and 27th Amendments. He argued at the time that the court would protect constitutional rights, especially the interests of smaller provinces. “However, in only one year, he has realised the death blow these amendments have dealt to the independence of judiciary and constitutional principles,” Ahmed said.

Ahmed noted the PPP itself had filed a review petition against the Supreme Court’s original decision awarding reserved seats to the PTI. He said the PPP and many in the PML-N were now belatedly realising that “to keep on feeding a crocodile in the hope it eats you last is not a winning strategy”. Even if the amendments were rolled back, he said, it would take decades to repair the damage.

Former additional attorney general Waqar Rana said the court had failed to uphold the Constitution, because it had neither the capacity nor the courage. “The constitutional court envisaged by the Charter of Democracy was quite different from the one which exists now,” he said.

Rana said Bilawal had shown he understood the principles his mother had given her life for, and urged him to show her perseverance and courage.

PTI welcomes the shift

PTI General Secretary Salman Akram Raja welcomed Bilawal’s remarks, including his questions about Supreme Court judgements that gave the PTI’s reserved seats to other parties and took away its election symbol. Raja said what Bilawal said had been obvious to political observers for four years, and the PPP itself had benefited from it. He said he expected Bilawal to stand with the opposition against the “plundering of Parliament as well as the judicial system”.

Raja also pointed to the human cost. He said thousands of PTI workers, including party founder Imran Khan and his wife Bushra Bibi, had been victims of the assault on the political system.

Concrete steps will matter more

Barrister Asad Rahim Khan said the PPP had disowned the 27th Amendment, and with it the court’s creation, after just one year, despite being its major co-author. “The first step towards solving a problem is acknowledging there is one,” he said. But he added that concrete steps would now matter far more than statements and press conferences.

Khan asked whether the PPP’s governor in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa would free PTI’s Taimur Jhagra, whether the party would return the reserved seats, and whether it would pursue the release of political prisoners, naming Imran Khan, Ali Wazir, Mahrang Baloch, Imaan Mazari, Ali Hadi Chattha and Yasmin Rashid. “There can be no ‘political reset’, not even the start of one, without all of the above,” he said.

Advocate Abid Saqi also welcomed Bilawal’s statement. He said the system could only survive if state structures were decolonised.

Why the speech matters

The Federal Constitutional Court was an old idea. The Charter of Democracy, signed by Benazir Bhutto and Nawaz Sharif in 2006, envisaged such a court. Bilawal himself had presented it as a way to protect the rights of smaller provinces. His speech at the Karachi Press Club this week marked a sharp turn. The government replied that the PPP was part of the same government. The PTI welcomed his call for a reset. The PTI backed Bilawal’s reset call.

The speech has already drawn a warning from the government. Rana Sanaullah warned that Bilawal’s remarks could lead to disqualification. The debate over new provinces, which sits behind the speech, is still running. The MQM-P has called for a December referendum on new provinces.

Frequently asked questions

What is the FCC?

A constitutional court created under the 27th Amendment, first proposed in the 2006 Charter of Democracy.

What did Bilawal say?

He said the 27th Amendment passed by brute majority, not consensus, and asked if the court could work with only the government’s confidence.

What did the lawyers say?

They welcomed his remarks but want concrete steps, including returning the reserved seats and freeing political prisoners.

What did the PTI say?

Salman Akram Raja welcomed it and urged Bilawal to stand with the opposition.

What happens next?

Lawyers say statements must be followed by action. The PPP has not said what it will do next.

Feature Pakistan News Desk
Feature Pakistan News Desk
Feature Pakistan News Desk is the editorial team of Feature Pakistan, an independent digital news platform based in Pakistan. The desk reports national, world, business, sports, technology, health and education news, and every story is cross-checked against multiple sources before it is published. To reach the newsroom — including for corrections — email featurepakistanofficial@gmail.com or use the Contact page at featurepakistan.com/contact-us/.

opinion